As they slumped to a deflating, demoralising
2-0 defeat at home to Manchester City, Aitor Karanka’s Middlesbrough side had finally come
full circle. Just over two years after a famous, fully deserved
FA Cup win at the Etihad marked the high point of the Basque manager’s reign, Boro crashed
out of the cup against the same team, by the same scoreline. Four days later,
Karanka is out of a job.
Sunday’s loss at the Riverside felt heavier, more
comprehensive than the eventual two-goal margin suggested, with Boro bamboozled
by the swashbuckling speed and skill of City’s Leroy Sane, David Silva and
Raheem Sterling. On home soil, Boro mustered just 31% possession. Their beleaguered
goalkeeper, Brad Guzan, was named man of the match. Top scorer this season with
just seven goals, Alvaro Negredo replaced injured January signing Rudy Gestede
in the first half, only to turn in another study in isolation as Boro’s sole
striker.
 |
Aitor Karanka left Middlesbrough on Thursday |
Such anaemic attacking performances had become the norm
under Karanka, with Middlesbrough’s failure to score in each of their last four
league fixtures contributing to the club’s slide to 19th in the Premier
League table. Boro still boast the fifth-meanest defence in the top flight,
even in spite of a winless run stretching back to before Christmas, but the
side’s lack of menace in attack eventually convinced Steve Gibson that Karanka
was no longer the right manager to stave off relegation to the Championship.
While Gibson will have thought long and hard over the
decision to replace Karanka, there is a certain inevitability to the former
Real Madrid assistant manager’s departure in his third full season on Teesside.
Indeed, Karanka’s reign at Middlesbrough has clear echoes of the problems his
friend and mentor, Jose Mourinho encountered in his third seasons at Real and
in his two spells at Chelsea. Although played out on different stages, the
narrative arc of promising beginning, glorious middle and fractious ending can
be seen in each of these three-act tenures.
 |
Mentor: Karanka was assistant to Jose Mourinho at Real Madrid |
Taking over from Tony Mowbray at 16th-placed Boro
in the November of 2013, Karanka tightened up the defence and steered the side
to the safety of 12th place in Championship table at the end of the
season. He began to impose a physical, but nonetheless possession-based playing
style on the team, too, exemplified by the January signings of towering centre
back Daniel Ayala and portly playmaker Lee Tomlin.
It wasn’t until Karanka’s side had their first pre-season
under their belt, however, that the side really started to sparkle. Of the
Spanish Armada signed in the summer of 2014, only Kike Garcia would shine on
Teesside, but Karanka’s other signings proved astute at Boro romped to 4th
place in the Championship. Adam Clayton added bite to the midfield alongside
the craft of Grant Leadbitter, while Chelsea loanee Patrick Bamford was a
revelation. A lightweight but wonderfully deft forward, the 21-year-old Bamford
scored 17 league goals and had a hand in many more on his way to Championship
Player of the Year. Boro’s lack of Premiership guile would be cruelly exposed
in a 2-0 play-off final defeat to Norwich City, but Karanka’s first full season
had brought the good times back to the Riverside.
 |
Patrick Bamford led Boro to the play offs in Karanka's first season |
Mourinho’s first-season successes at Chelsea are
well-documented, with a league title in 2004-05 and a third-place finish in
2013-14, but he also made a promising start with Karanka as his assistant manager at
Real Madrid in 2010-11. Succeeding Manuel Pellegrini, Mourinho led Los Merengues to victory in the Copa del
Rey, ending a three-year trophy drought in the process, although a 5-0 league
hammering to Barcelona revealed the gap still to be bridged between the two
sides.
The similarities between Karanka and Mourinho’s second
seasons are similarly striking, with notable triumphs for the two managers in
Madrid and Middlesbrough alike, as well as in West London. In Karanka’s second
full season, his Boro side went a step further than his first campaign,
claiming automatic promotion as runners-up in the Championship. The defence, in
the Mourinho mould, was nigh-on impregnable as Ben Gibson emerged as a perfect
partner for Ayala in the back line. There were memorable moments, too, with a
3-0 win at Brighton in December a particular a highlight, as Boro ended their
hosts’ unbeaten record in some style.
 |
Boro achieved promotion in Aitor Karanka's second season |
However, it could be said that even as he steered his team
to promotion, Karanka’s faults were already beginning to emerge. With Bamford
and Tomlin both trying their luck in the Premier League, goals, flair and
creativity were at a premium, as Boro managed to score five fewer goals than
the previous campaign but still finish higher in the table. Indeed, no side in
the Championship’s top six scored fewer than Middlesbrough that season.
The manager’s signings began to become increasingly erratic,
too, with puzzling continental prospects (Julian de Sart and Kike Sola,
anyone?) linking up with grizzled Championship veterans such as Jordan Rhodes
and David Nugent. Only Gaston Ramirez, brought in on loan from Southampton in
January, was an unqualified success in adding seven goals from midfield.
 |
Underwhelming: Kike Sola failed to make an impact on Teesside |
While Karanka did return to win promotion with
Middlesbrough, Jose Mourinho’s second seasons have been similarly successful,
although often tinged with the same grinding pragmatism. Despite winning titles
in both of his second seasons at Chelsea, it is worth noting that in both of his
second seasons at Stamford Bridge, his side have been “Champions elect” by
Christmas before slowing down considerably on the final straight. The Frank
Lampard-inspired 2005-06 vintage saw their lead over Manchester United cut by
half in an awful March, while the Hazard-Costa axis of 2013-14 had a similar
late-season wobble punctuated by draws and scrappy victories, as the January
addition of Juan Cuadrado curtailed the fine form of Willian and Oscar.
In Mourinho’s defence (no pun intended), his second season
at Real Madrid was more or less faultless: a La Liga title won with record
totals in points and goals, and denied a place in the Champions League final
only by the iron law of Bayern Munich winning a penalty shoot-out.
 |
Mourinho, Ronaldo and co romped to the La Liga title in 2011-12 |
If the Real Madrid exception proves the rule, it’s now
possible examine the point where Karanka and Mourinho’s teams really fall
apart: the third season.
In Karanka’s case, it is more excusable, with Middlesbrough
moving up to the Premier League and lacking the resources of the league’s
biggest spenders. Even discounting Boro’s relative lack of financial muscle in
the top division, however, the Spanish coach has made some unusual signings and
transfers throughout this campaign. From summer’s sale of rangy winger Albert Adomah
to Aston Villa, to the recent reticence to play Ayala since his return from
injury, Karanka has made a number of odd calls.
 |
Influential: but Albert Adomah was sold after promotion |
Perhaps the most egregious omissions are those of Bamford,
who re-signed on a permanent deal in January, and Ramirez. While Negredo
remains a dangerous finisher in the penalty box, he has recently been starved
of service, with only the erratic Adama Traore and the static Cristhian Stuani
for support. Asked about Bamford’s absence recently, Karanka only commented
that he needed “18 fighters” for matchdays, which makes the initial decision to
purchase the talented, but rather laconic forward hard to explain.
Similarly to his mentor, Karanka also found himself at odds
with the club’s ownership in his third season. He recently bemoaned the lack of
investment in the squad, despite Gibson sanctioning January moves for Bamford
and Gestede, who cost £5.5 million and £7 million respectively.
In the third season of Mourinho’s first spell at Chelsea,
the problem was more with who the Stamford Bridge hierarchy did bring in,
rather than who they failed to. Andriy Shevchenko, a personal favourite of
Roman Abramovich, rocked up about three years past his devastating peak, while
young stars Salomon Kalou and John Obi Mikel largely flattered to deceive.
Khalid Boulahrouz, meanwhile, didn’t even manage to deceive.
 |
Frosty: Mourinho struggled to get the best out of Andriy Shevchenko |
Mourinho added an FA Cup in 2006-07 but Chelsea lost out to
Manchester United in a tight title race, unable to keep pace with the firepower
of Cristiano Ronaldo and Wayne Rooney. By September, he had departed in the
wake of a 1-1 Champions League draw with Rosenborg in front of a half-full
Stamford Bridge.
At Real Madrid, Aitor Karanka looked on as his mentor’s
third season unravelled into trophyless catastrophe, with the
infamous eye-poke
on Tito Vilanova a particularly embarrassing nadir for club and manager alike. Even Real's own players felt the Portuguese’s ire in his final season at the
Bernabeu, with Pepe slammed in the press and replaced in central defence by a
19-year-old Raphael Varane after he dared to question the wisdom of dropping
club legend Iker Casillas.
John Terry was scapegoated in similar fashion after Chelsea
made a poor start to their title defence in 2015-16, with Mourinho slipping into a deep paranoia in towards the end of his second spell at Stamford
Bridge, accusing his squad of “betraying” him before eventually departing in
December. Referees, opposition managers and club physio Eva Carneiro were all
blamed for defeats, with Mourinho keen to look anywhere except the mirror when apportioning
blame.
 |
Departed: but Karanka's replacement can still keep Boro up |
While the symptoms of third season syndrome have brought the
same managerial morbidity to Aitor Karanka as suffered by his mentor Mourinho,
Middlesbrough do at least have a chance of retaining their place in the Premier
League. Sitting just three points behind
17th-placed Crystal Palace, and with a superior goal difference to most of their relegation rivals, whoever takes charge of Boro for the remaining 11
games of the season will feel confident of securing survival after reviewing
the fixture list. Home games against Burnley, Sunderland and a comfortably
mid-table Southampton look eminently winnable, as do trips to Swansea and Hull.
If the shackles that seemed to grip the side in the last
months of Karanka’s tenure can be loosened, Boro might be able to start
planning dreaming of how to avoid their own third season syndrome in the top
flight.